The Pitt And The Pendulum: The Pause We Lose In The ER

-

Louie dies, and they stop. But not for long. The ER never allows long. But long enough.

In The Pitt, Louie is what we would call a “frequent flier” in our ER lingo. Chronic illness. In and out. Uninsured. System-worn. The kind of patient whose name is familiar before his face comes into view. And yet, when he dies, the team does not reduce him to utilization metrics or comorbidities. They remember him. They speak about his cheerfulness. The way he always had something kind to say to the nurses. The way he made their night shifts lighter. They celebrate his life.

That pause was the most accurate thing I have seen on medical television in years.

A lot has been written about The Pitt. It feels like a spiritual successor to ER, stripped of the orchestral swell and early-2000s heroics. It stands in quiet contrast to the romance and entanglements of Grey's Anatomy. People call it grittier. More grounded. Less interested in saviors and more attentive to institutional realities.

I have worked in two emergency departments, one in Houston, one in Karachi. Watching The Pitt felt like looking into a mirror that reflected both, though unevenly.

What it gets right is the strain. The boarding. The moral fatigue. The violence against healthcare workers. The medical misinformation. The patient who is both vulnerable and angry. Ditto where the staff is concerned. And in tandem, the staff who survive by staying aligned.

But that moment when Louie is pronounced dead lingered with me. In the United States, I have stood in rooms after codes were called. There is a choreography to it. The pronouncement. The silence. Sometimes a debrief. Social workers who step in. Mandated processes that kick in. There is, at least, some acknowledgment that something human has just ended. It is imperfect. Bureaucratic at times. But it exists.

In Karachi, it often did not in the same structured way. We had Dead On Arrivals. We had phosphine-poisoned siblings laid side by side under white sheets. We had children whose rigor mortis had already declared what we could not undo. I remember pulling a curtain across the resuscitation bay, not for them but for us, because the ER does not stop. There were other patients waiting.

There was rarely a formal debrief. No routine counselor presence. No structured reflection we could rely on. We moved on because we had to. I wrote about that weight years later, trying to give it shape in words we never had time to say.


Some systems make more space for grief. Others are forced toward throughput. This is not a moral judgment. It’s structural. Emergency medicine swings like a pendulum. Between pause and pressure. Between systems that allow ritual and systems that demand endurance. Between visibility and silence. Between belonging and foreignness. The pendulum does not stop.

These differences are not limited to death alone. The Pitt also shows violence: the raised voices, the entitlement, the fraying civility toward exhausted clinicians. I recognized that too.

In Texas, I was once “fired” by a patient’s mother who told me she wanted a “real American doctor.” A complaint later described me as “dark-skinned… sounded Pakistani.” I was American. Board-certified. Fully trained. And still foreign. Belonging, I learned, is not guaranteed by a passport. I wrote about that encounter in a piece called “Margarita,” where the person who ultimately steadied me was not a senior physician but a hospital cleaning lady from the housekeeping department who whispered reassurance when my daughter lay in the NICU of the same children’s hospital where I practiced.

In Karachi, the aggression felt different. Less legalistic. More physical, shaped by different constraints. Parents arguing with each other at the bedside. Entitlement layered not only with expectation but with scarcity. Violence exists in every emergency department. It just sounds different.

Child abuse is another place where the mirror doesn’t reflect evenly. In the U.S., even in a children’s hospital emergency department, we saw rape cases frequently. Mandated reporting. Sealed forensic kits opened only by SANE nurses, Sexual Assault Nurse Examiners. Social workers, chaplains, security personnel, and child protective services were embedded in the pediatric emergency department. The process was uncomfortable, procedural, sometimes retraumatizing, but it did bring the harm into the open. The system demanded visibility.

In Pakistan, far fewer cases reached us in formal channels. That does not mean abuse occurred less. It often meant silence was stronger. Stigma heavier. Medicolegal pathways less consistently accessible. The child who has been broken does not always arrive under fluorescent lights with a social worker waiting. I have written about those children too, the ones whose stories were carried in fragments, if at all.

Watching The Pitt, I appreciated that it allows abuse to be named. That it shows systems trying, however imperfectly. That it does not trivialize the moral injury of standing in those rooms.

And yet television, by necessity, contains the chaos. It gives it edges. What it cannot fully show is what follows the shift. The numbness in the car ride home. The irritability that shows up at family dinner. The way unprocessed grief calcifies into cynicism if left unattended. In Karachi, we had no routine debrief. In the U.S., we had more structure, but even structure does not guarantee healing.

Across continents, one thing stayed constant: team is oxygen. In Texas, it was the residents and nurses who caught each other before collapse. In Karachi, it was colleagues who held the line when ICU beds were unavailable and more children kept arriving. I named them once in a farewell letter after thirteen years in the ER in Karachi because without them, the weight would not have been carryable. The Pitt understands that too. It does not portray lone heroes. It portrays interdependence.

So yes, I admire this show.

I admire that it pauses for Louie.

I admire that it honors the homeless and the uninsured. I admire that it shows healthcare workers as strained but still human.

But watching Louie’s memorial, I also felt something else: a quiet ache for the pauses we rarely took in Karachi. For the curtains we pulled instead. For the words we never spoke because another ambulance had already arrived.

Emergency medicine is not drama. It is bearing witness.

Sometimes with ritual. Sometimes without it.

I am grateful The Pitt shows the pause.

Because in many emergency departments, the pause is the first thing we lose.

from Narrative Medicine

Acknowledgment: Originally published in the Express Tribune: The Pitt and the Pendulum. 

Additional Reading:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Of Cigarette Packs and Elephant Dung

-
Image
Where can you go to see the following? (1) Creative photography on cigarette packs. (2) Innovative co-existence with elephants. Answer: Sri Lanka. Last summer, my family and I went on a week-long sojourn to Sri Lanka. That it happened to coincide with the heat wave in Karachi needs further explanation, in case you think I created a respite for myself primarily because I wanted to get away from angry sun gods. Truth be told, I felt guilty that I was vacationing in a tropical environment while the heat-facilitated death toll rose in Karachi… Anyway, after that trip, there was a strong urge to write about the island. I'm not a travel writer, but after experiencing the ‘wonders of Sri Lanka’, I couldn't stop myself from telling you about that land. Although considered a ‘developing nation’, there were aspects to the country that completely defied that label. As I was visiting from Pakistan, the analogy thus created was insightful. A runner's tale "Are you a...
Read more

Sitting at Nadir’s Table

-
Image
We shared beginnings - different years, same places: Karachi Grammar School and Aga Khan University. A thin but sturdy thread in the doctor fraternity. We also shared the country club in Karachi, and in its gym is where we often crossed paths. Not to spot each other’s lifts but to swap maps of the world. Like the time I was heading to San Francisco for a conference and Nadir, between sets, gave me a street-by-street guide to the city, covering both work and after hours. He could have been moonlighting as a tour guide. That trip of mine went fantastically.  He was never my official career counselor, yet we had enough one-to-one sessions in the club’s garden to make it seem otherwise. He would talk about being at AKU, then moving away, shifting between academic medicine and private practice. When I spoke about my own trajectory in similar terms, he was always gracious in his mentoring. Later I realized he was like that with many others too. His funeral, with its sea of people ca...
Read more

The Observer by Natasha Khalid (guest writer)

-
Image
Photo-credit: Saniya Kamal, AKU MBBS ' 18 I enter the corridor of my new work place. I’m welcomed and introduced all around. For some reason, best known to her, the human resource lady took so much of my time that I am already pissed and looking angry. I don’t feel comfortable in this different setup and I terribly miss my old working place. Every single thing about it which previously used to get on my nerves is acutely missed. However, I succumb to my new work because it has been over a year since I practiced medicine and the sole reason for me to be here is to get distracted from my mental chaos and to focus elsewhere. In a matter of hours I find myself adjusting here, understanding the work dynamics, and the system around here. It’s easy - not challenging, likely because there’s ample time at hand which I can utilize to study while earning. Not a bad deal!    This is a dialysis department of a semi-private hospital. Every single patient here is dependent on dia...
Read more